
Even as a seasoned visitor to the MAC Pro store, I still get overwhelmed by their vast selection of foundations. Sometimes I get so wrapped up in the “latest” launch that I forget some of the tried and true formulas that established MAC as a top tier makeup brand in the first place. So, in an effort to relieve some of that confusion, I’ve crunched the numbers from both Makeupalley.com and TotalBeauty.com and have put together a list of the the Top 5 MAC Foundations. Drumroll please…
#1 = MAC FACE & BODY FOUNDATION ($32)
Average TotalBeauty.com Rating =8.6/10; Average Makeupalley.com Rating = 4/5
Product Description from MAC.com: “A water-based, water-resistant foundation that provides long-lasting, natural coverage for face and/or body. Ideal for all skin types. Face and Body Foundation provides sheer, natural looking coverage in an easy to blend, water-resistant formula. The long-lasting formula is available in a wide range of colours and contains several emollients to help moisturize and condition the skin. It delivers professional looking results that meet the exacting standards of beauty photography and is ideal for perfecting the face and body.”
*From the reviews on Makeupalley.com, it appears that many people LOVE that this foundation feels light and sheer, yet provides good, solid coverage. Those that submitted negative reviews often commented that it became shiny/oily-looking as the day went on. These reviewers commonly had combination – to -oily skin types.
#2 = MAC STUDIO FIX POWDER PLUS FOUNDATION ($26)
Average TotalBeauty.com Rating = 9.1/10; Average Makeupalley.com Rating = 3.6/5
Product Description from MAC.com: “A one-step application of foundation and powder. Gives skin a smooth, flawless, all-matte, full-coverage finish. Long-wearing: lasts for up to eight hours. A real all-in-one. The choice of pros, and a long time favourite of MAC fans.”
*The consensus on Makeupalley.com seems to be that it is best to apply the Studio Fix Powder Foundation with a brush as opposed to the included sponge. Many reviewers like the “airbrush finish” this foundation gives and the amount of coverage it provides. Those that submitted negative reviews commented that they didn’t think it had a lot of staying power.
#3 = MAC STUDIO TECH ($29.50)
Average TotalBeauty.com Rating = 7.9/10; Average Makeupalley.com Rating = 3.5/5
Product Description from MAC.com: “Totally tech. A tri-system blend of water, emollients and powder. Looks solid, glides on as a soft, creamy emulsion. Provides a natural matte, powder-perfect finish. Smooth to blend, easy to work with: provides a full range of coverage. Water-cooled – refreshes and hydrates skin. Light diffusing: softens lines, creates a fresh, flawless finish. Good on all skin types. Studio Tech is dermatologist tested, ophthalmologist tested, non-acnegenic and safe for contact lens wearers.”
*As with the Studio Fix Powder Foundation, most reviewers on Makeupalley.com advise using Studio Tech with a brush as opposed to the included sponge. It seems that reviewers are pretty divided between those that love the amount of coverage it provides (flawless!!) and those that think it might provide too much coverage, causing an almost “mask-like” effect. (If you find this foundation is looking “mask-like”, I would suggest putting a few dots of the foundation on with a brush, and then blending it out with a damp sponge.)
#4 = MAC STUDIO SCULPT SPF 15 ($29.50)
Average TotalBeauty.com Rating = 7.7/10; Average Makeupalley.com Rating = 3.6/5
Product Description from MAC.com: “A creamy, luxurious, gel-based foundation that provides medium buildable to high coverage with a natural satin finish. Hydrating, instantly revitalizes the skin while keeping it looking smooth, soft and plush. Long-wearing, water-resistant.”
*Makeupalley.com reviewers LOVE how the gel-texture provides great coverage and is also very buildable (without looking cakey). Many reviewers emphasized how the finished product still looks like “real skin,” not overly made-up. Those that submitted negative reviews mentioned said that it looked “greasy” on their combination/oily akin after a few hours and tended to settle into their pores.
#5 = MAC STUDIO STICK SPF 15 ($29.50)
Average TotalBeauty.com Rating = 7.1/10; Average Makeupalley.com Rating = 3.9/5
Product Description from MAC.com: “A creamy smooth stick foundation with medium+ coverage for a natural flaw-free finish. Stick system provides smooth twist-up action: precise application and fast, even touch-ups. Available in 15 shades. Stick with it!”
*Makeupalley.com reviewers love the variability and blendability of the Studio Stick. Some reviewers use it as their concealer, others use it as their foundation. Some reviewers swear by blending it on with your warm fingertips, others say it’s best to use a damp sponge or brush. Then there are those who love to blend a little with their favorite moisturizer to create their own tinted moisturizer. Those that wrote negative reviews often cited that they didn’t feel like they got very much product for the price. Other negative reviewers mentioned that they felt it made them look “greasy” as the day went on.
What about you? What is YOUR favorite MAC foundation?